Religious dog xenofiction, why not? Mild spoilers ahead.
Barley is a dog who lives a simple life during Jesus' time. But then one day his loving owners vanish and he ends up with a different, more flawed man named Samid. Despite Barley's bond with Samid being not as easygoing and simple as with his previous owners', the duo soon become close. All the while Samid and his peers are struggling with being poor, the words of a mysterious Teacher are causing a stir in the community. Will Barley and Samid live together happily ever after?
I quite liked this book, Barley was a likable lead and I was very invested in the many people surrounding him. From Duv and Adah, his first loving owners, to Samid, a flawed but well-meaning man, to a possible new owner in the future after he gets separated from Samid. The human characters were all reasonably fleshed-out, and I think Samid is my favorite character just because of how realistic he felt. He's not always the most morally upstanding guy, but given his situation you totally get where he's coming from. And his fate was pretty bittersweet.
Barley himself was also a decent main character, however he did not have as much personality as the human characters, being a non-speaking, pretty much non-anthropomorphized dog. Which is totally fine, he serves his purpose as lead/framing device for the story of the human characters well. But if you were looking to go into this to get more of a distinct personality from the dog you might be disappointed.
I also kinda wish that Jesus did more in this story, as in, that he interacted more directly with Barley and the human characters relevant to Barley. This story isn't so much a story intersecting with Jesus' crucifixion, but rather happening alongside it. Jesus is definitely present, but he is much more of a side character and it's not until the crucifixion itself that he directly interacts with one of our lead characters.
And I mean, I don't think that this is bad or anything, but I can see people who wanted to see Jesus interact more directly with our main story being a bit disappointed because there's so little direct interaction between the Messiah and the main story. Jesus is definitely a relevant person in this story, don't get me wrong, but he's not a key player in the main story until the very end. And, with this being religious fiction, I think it's not odd to expect Jesus to interact a little more with the main story/characters.
Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with a free review copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Rating: 3.5/5

No comments:
Post a Comment