Saturday, November 14, 2026

Book Review: Mia's Tiger by Paula Harrison (Animagicals #1)

 

I like tigers so needless to say I picked this up. Spoilers ahead.

Mia is a girl who is sent to a school for Animagicals, shapeshifters. Here, she'll learn more about how to find her true form, and mischief seems to be afoot at the Animagical school. Can Mia and her new friends figure out what is going on in time to stop the bad guys?

I guess that I like the setup for this story, but the execution left a lot to be desired. For one, I didn't connect at all with the characters. They felt painfully generic and bland and forgettable. I can name almost no traits for any of these characters, and even their names of most slip my mind as well. 

The world-building felt lack-luster as well. Shapeshifters are a cool concept, and I also like the idea of every shapeshifter having a "true" form they connect with the most (like a tiger for Mia), but the rest felt so lackluster.

Take for example day one of the school. You'd think that the kids would start their classes by learning how to control their shifting better, how to adapt to living as various different animal species, maybe some history or basics of the Animagicals, etc. 

But nope, instead literally their first day of class assumes they can fully control their shifting already, and gives them a challenge to complete with no guidance instead. What the heck kind of initiation class is this? No self-respecting school would start out with a complicated challenge (basically a test) for something this advanced when its students have barely grasped the basics of the subject (in this case shapeshifting).  

The school also doesn't teach basic necessary subjects like for example history, geography, languages and maths/calculus. Instead the school is only focused on "teaching" (using that term loosely here, it's more like giving challenges) shapeshifting and pretty much nothing else. How do you expect these children to function in adult society after they graduate from this school, if they weren't even taught basic subjects they need to survive as adults?

There's also the aspect that Animagicals who lose their shapeshifting powers (in a way a disability in this universe) are literally kicked out of the magical land where the other shapeshifters live, instead of being accommodated for their disability and being given a support system. Massive yikes from me.

Stuff like this just makes me think that the author barely thought about these things when developing this world and these aspects. And it greatly hampered my enjoyment of the book. Skip this one.

Rating: 2.5/5 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment