This one interested me, I don't think I've read a dire wolf xenofiction before! Spoiler alert.
Torro is a young dire wolf pup, son of the leader. One day he and his best friend Elsie become kidnapped by a rival pack. He and Elsie manage to escape, but after this Elsie changes. Meanwhile two other pack members of Torro's, Graydart and Sinsate, are missing and going on their own individual journeys, involving dangerous sabertooths and mammoths.
This gets rated super low on Goodreads and similar review sites, and I mean...I
get why some people rate it like that...but personally I still found
myself lowkey enjoying it.
Is this objectively a very good book?
I'd say no. It throws a lot of concepts at the wall and not all of them
stick (there's lemurs which have spears and mammoths that live in
castles and enjoy partaking in skinning dire wolves, for one). The main villain turns out to be Elsie, a literal child of only a few months old, and her plan is pretty nonsensical. There's also a ton of grammar/punctuation errors, and
there's not a lot of character development/distinct character writing.
But
I can't help it, I still found myself at least lowkey interested in
this. I like some of the world-building (even if it doesn't adhere to
reality or make a lot of sense, the concepts can still be fun and
unique), and I was still quite engaged in Torro/Elsie's part of the
story. The part with Graydart and Sinsate kinda jumped the shark for me,
though.
Mixed bag of a book, but I cannot hate it. Had too much
fun with it for that, even if I totally see other people's reasoning for
disliking it.
While this book does have a lot of typos, I've
legit read books which have a gazillion more, so by "published book with
a lot of typos" standards this is still pretty tame. Not that it
excuses publishing and asking money for an unfinished product which
clearly needed more revisions, of course, but it didn't bother me as much when I've
experienced much worse.
Rating: 3/5
PS I guess I cannot in good conscience
put this in my "wolf books" tag on here because dire wolves are no longer scientifically classified as (close relatives of) wolves.

No comments:
Post a Comment